I got the shades carefree and offbeat. Tbh there isn't much of a difference between the two shades on me but I can't blame it on the product since my lips are naturally a bit darker. I do like that it gives a decent tint enough for "no makeup" makeup days but it doesn't last after eating. I also find it a bit drying so I usually layer with a lip balm or lip oil. I tend to like watery tints but hate the strong fragrance in some. I was surprised that these tints don't have a strong fragrance it just smells like fresh strawberries which I really like!